Kulczycka, Dorota - red. nauk. ; Sztyber, Radosław - red.
This study refers to a problem of confusing similarity between two XVII centuary literary worksconcerning the Battle of Khotyn (1621), i.e. "Chorągiew sauromatcka" written by Marcin Paszkowskiand Prokop Zbigniewski`s "Diariusz". The poet of the House of Zadora used to plagiarized in most ofhis early writings which was quickly proven in professional literature. A question arisen whetherPaszkowski did also plagiarize in his latest known work or did he wrote it all by himself? ; A thorough research clearly indicates that we are surely dealing with a prosed diary original (Zbigniewski) and its poematic duplication (Paszkowski). "Chorągiew sauromatcka" brought out a lot of controversies [e.g. the chronology of printings devoted to the Battle of Khotyn or the Paszkowski`s presence (absence?) during warfare], even the monography of the author of "Bitwy znamienite" wasn`t sufficient enough to answer the problematic questions. The proofs for dishonest methodology have been recently pointed out by Radosław Sztyber. ; The newest research also shed some light on that matter. The outline of the state of the studies presents as follows. Paszkowski purposely and for the propaganda reasons gave a misleading description of the type of polish troops. He failed to provide objective information about the end of the Khotyn Battle (e.g. a number of injured or killed soldiers on both sides). He used a distinctive Zbigniewski`s vocabulary to characterize the battleship. The poet was also wrong about several facts related to Grand Hetman Jan Karol Chodkiewicz. ; He copied and incorporated some lines from Jan Kochanowski`s "Szachy". Paszkowski gave an account of the war straight from the Zbigniewski`s work as well. He presented polish propositions for a peace treaty as a final agreement between two enemy sides. Finally, what the deeper comparison shows, he may have also used a third source in his poem to plagiaries from. In that case (what requires a deeper insight) the whole content of "Chorągiew sauromatcka" would turned out to be a mixture from several other works.
Zielona Góra: Oficyna Wydawnicza Uniwersytetu Zielonogórskiego
Zeszyty Naukowe Uniwersytetu Zielonogórskiego: Seria Scripta Humana, tom 2
Biblioteka Uniwersytetu Zielonogórskiego
2024-02-19
2020-04-09
153
https://zbc.uz.zgora.pl/publication/62447
Sztyber, Radosław Kulczycka, Dorota - red. nauk. Sztyber, Radosław - red.
Wójcicki, Kazimierz Władysław (1807-1879)
Sztyber, Radosław Kulczycka, Dorota - red. nauk. Mikołajczak, Małgorzata (1966 -) - red.
Seul, Anastazja (1961- ) Kulczycka, Dorota - red. nauk. Mikołajczak, Małgorzata (1966 -) - red.
Winek, Teresa Sztyber, Radosław - red. nacz.
Jazownik, Maria Brzezińska, Ewa - red. nauk. Jazownik, Maria - red. nauk. Jazownik, Leszek - red. nauk.
Jazownik, Maria Jazownik, Leszek Brzezińska, Ewa - red. nauk. Jazownik, Maria - red. nauk. Jazownik, Leszek - red. nauk.